Younger Dryas Comet: What Randall Carlson Gets Wrong

UFO & Aliens

Younger Dryas Comet: What Randall Carlson Gets Wrong

Younger Dryas, Carlson, and the Limits of a Catastrophe Claim Summary Proponents of the Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis argue that around 12,900 years ago an extraterrestrial event such as a comet airburst produced a…

December 27, 2025 • 3 min read • Art Grindstone

Art Grindstone is the hard-nosed storyteller behind Unexplained.co, a veteran investigator whose life’s work sits at the crossroads of the paranormal, fringe science, and the shadows most people try not to look into. With decades spent chasing impossible stories — black-budget psychic programs, vanished Cold War experiments, desert rituals that sparked UFO waves, and the strange phenomena buried in America’s forgotten backroads — Art brings a rare combination of skepticism, awe, and journalistic precision. He’s not here to debunk. He’s not here to blindly believe. He follows the evidence wherever it leads — even when it leads someplace deeply uncomfortable. Known for his immersive, cinematic style and his ability to turn obscure research into gripping narrative, Art has built a devoted following across podcasts, long-form features, documentaries, and serialized investigations. His interviews are direct. His analysis is unflinching. His voice has become a staple in the modern paranormal renaissance — the guy people turn to when a story is too strange, too complex, or too dangerous for anyone else to touch. Off-mic, Art works with a distributed network of researchers, archivists, and field operatives who help surface the stories mainstream media ignores. On-mic, he transforms their findings into meticulous, high-impact reporting that refuses to insult the intelligence of true believers. His philosophy is simple: Take the phenomenon seriously. Treat the audience with respect. Tell the story as if the world depends on it — because sometimes it does. When Art Grindstone digs into a case, he isn’t just chasing a mystery. He’s tracing the fault lines of reality itself.

Younger Dryas, Carlson, and the Limits of a Catastrophe Claim

Summary
Proponents of the Younger Dryas Impact Hypothesis argue that around 12,900 years ago an extraterrestrial event such as a comet airburst produced a hemispheric layer of anomalous materials, abrupt cooling, widespread fires, and biological and cultural disruptions. Randall Carlson and Stefan Burns revisit these ideas in a recent conversation, mixing scientific points with personal reflection.

Evidence Often Cited
Reported markers include a carbonaceous ‘black mat’ at many stratigraphic sites, peaks in platinum group elements, magnetic microspherules, meltglass, and claimed nanodiamond concentrations. Some individual sites, like Abu Hureyra, have reported high-temperature materials that supporters interpret as impact-related.

Advertisement

Uncertainties and Critique
Many claimed markers have been difficult to replicate consistently across independent labs and sites. Reviews and follow-up studies have found site-to-site variability, ambiguous formation pathways for some proxies, and alternative non-impact explanations such as wildfires, local geology, or human activity. The overall picture remains contested and unresolved in mainstream Quaternary science.

Carlson’s Framing
Carlson situates the hypothesis within a broader narrative of episodic catastrophic events and includes personal spiritual experiences from the late 1960s and early 1970s as influencing his perspective. That framing appeals to curiosity about deep-time catastrophes but mixes scientific evidence with interpretive and experiential claims that require separate evaluation.

Bottom Line
The Younger Dryas interval is real and abrupt changes are well documented. Whether a singular extraterrestrial catastrophe is the primary trigger remains an open debate. Stronger, independently reproducible geochemical and stratigraphic correlations across continents would be required to elevate the impact hypothesis from intriguing to widely accepted.