Five members of the climate change group Just Stop Oil have been sentenced to up to five years in prison after being convicted of conspiracy to cause a public nuisance. This case has sparked a debate on whether this is a stifling of the right to protest or an appropriate response to major disruptions to UK infrastructure. Let’s delve into the facts, the judge’s sentencing remarks, and the potential for a successful appeal.
Key Takeaways
- Five members of Just Stop Oil were sentenced to up to five years in prison for conspiracy to cause a public nuisance.
- The offense is relatively new, under Section 78 of the Police, Crime, Sentencing, and Courts Act of 2022.
- The group planned to disrupt traffic on the M25 Motorway by having protesters climb onto gantries.
- The judge cited six aggravating factors, including previous convictions and the high level of disruption caused.
- The sentences are likely to be upheld if appealed, as they are not considered manifestly excessive.
The Facts of the Case
Five individuals—Roger Hallam, Daniel Shaw, Luis Lancaster, Lucia Whitaker de Abu, and Crescor Gethin—were charged with conspiracy to cause a public nuisance. This offense is contrary to Section 78 of the Police, Crime, Sentencing, and Courts Act of 2022. The group, known for disruptive protests, aimed to promote their climate change message and influence government policy.
The specific offense involved a conspiracy to disrupt traffic on the M25 Motorway by having protesters climb onto gantries, causing gridlock. The key evidence was an audio and video recording of a Zoom meeting on November 2, 2022, recorded by an undercover journalist from The Sun newspaper. This meeting was to arrange protests leading to significant disruption.
Advertisement
The Judge’s Sentencing Remarks
The judge outlined the specific contributions of each group member. Roger Hallam gave a lengthy pep talk justifying the protests. Daniel Shaw chaired the meeting and was involved in organizing recruitment and training. The other three inspired would-be climbers based on their own experiences.
As a result of the group’s actions, 45 protesters climbed or attempted to climb gantries on the M25 between November 7 and 10, 2022, causing an estimated £750,000 in economic costs and significant public disruption.
On July 18, 2024, Roger Hallam was sentenced to five years imprisonment, while the others received four years each. The judge’s sentencing remarks, spanning 23 pages, provide detailed reasoning for these sentences.
Advertisement
